No Ponyo Bootlegs, Please

Alright, time to get back to writing on the Ghibli blog as well as Videogames of the Damned. Somebody sent me an email recently, asking where to find subtitled bootleg copies of Ponyo on a Cliff by the Sea. I don't remember if I've talked about this subject, so perhaps now is a good time to address it.

Here on Conversations on Ghibli, I've pointed many of you to where you could find various versions of the Miyazaki-Takahata canon, particularly their works that have never been released here in the West. It's a slippery slope where copywright law is concerned, but I've tried to follow some code of ethics. First and foremost, my greatest concern is for the original artists. I write this blog to promote the animated works of great, wonderfully talented artists. Some of them have achieved a degree of fame - Miyazaki's last few movies, for instance - but to a great extent the canon remains undiscovered on our shores.

There are various reasons for this, cultural reasons, business reasons. And we've discussed them in great detail. What results is a great body of work in film and television that deserves to be discovered by Westerners. Thankfully, most of these films are available overseas on DVD. If that's the case, it's only a matter of purchasing an import, when English subtitles exist. Where no English subtitles exist, there are the "fan subs," subtitle projects created by anime fans as a labor of love.

What I do not condone or advocate is piracy. I have no desire to steal money from the pockets of Ghibli or their peers. If you're a working artist, then you'll understand the feeling. You need to be properly compensated for your work. Otherwise, well, it's a lot tougher to be a successful artist without the money. Ya gotta pay the rent, kids.

So what does this have to do with Ponyo? Simple, really. The film is currently in theatres in Japan, and is headed around the globe. It will be seen here in the US in 2009, and that's really the way you want to see Miyazaki's latest work of art. You wouldn't be happy crouched over a small computer screen. You need to watch the film the way it was intended.

I haven't bothered to search the internet for any subtitled pirate copy of Ponyo. I thought I would be tempted months ago, but now I'm perfectly willing to wait. It is a special moment to watch a movie for the first time. You won't get that experience back, no matter how many times you see it again. That thrill of discovery is what I love about the movies, especially in a theatre. That's the way movies were meant to be seen.

So I hope you'll spare me any questions about where to download Ponyo, or where to find subtitles. I seriously doubt you've seen everything that has been fansubbed or released on DVD. Get caught up on those first. Then watch some Criterion Collection DVD's. Then read a couple books. Ponyo will be there when the time comes. Be patient.

5 comments:

Klaus said...

couldn't put it any better! agree 100%

Anonymous said...

it's hard for me to see ghibli films where i live, so i need to download them to be able to see them. i have many on dvd, and i will probably buy ponyo as well.

i did see Ponyo on an excellent cam screener the other day though. and for the first time i was disappointed in a miyazaki film. of course it could have been the format, i truly hope so. but i don't think it was the case. i didn't like ponyo the character, i didn't like the pompous music - allthough in parts it was beautiful- for the most it was horribly disneyfied. there were some parts of the films i loved, but overall i just didn't like ponyo's character. it might sound shallow, but if they had made her cute and a little older it would have been a much better film.

Dave said...

"What I do not condone or advocate is piracy. I have no desire to steal money from the pockets of Ghibli or their peers. If you're a working artist, then you'll understand the feeling. You need to be properly compensated for your work. Otherwise, well, it's a lot tougher to be a successful artist without the money. Ya gotta pay the rent, kids."

---

Absolutely. This is well put , Daniel.

Friends, if we don't pay for movies and other works of art legitimately we will eventually have no original content (no GOOD original content, just YouTubery junk) being produced because it won't be worth it for the artists to basically work for free . Animator can't pay the rent, can't afford to buy groceries , can't buy pencils and paper ... then animator doesn't make any more animation. Simple to understand , yes ?

Now, on the other hand, if a company just sits on a film or tv series that deserves to be seen and is locked away in a a vault somewhere I have no problem with someone posting a print on YouTube. If the company which owns it will put it out on DVD then I'll buy the DVD (who wants to put up with watching crappy YouTube video quality if you can get it on DVD ? Not me. ) I don't see that serious animation fans posting rare work on YouTube or elsewhere is the same thing as bootlegging or piracy. If anything the motivation on the part of people like Daniel is to nudge the studios who own these films out of their complacency and to give the films a proper release to a new generation of audiences who would embrace these films if they only knew they existed.

Armen said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Armen said...

Great Article! A complex topic dealt with a few simple/clear paragraphs! Especially paragraph #4.

Copyright © 2006-2014 - Ghibli Blog - Studio Ghibli, Animation and the Arts